Creating College Lists and Navigating Admission Decisions


Blank-3IESolutions counsels all of our clients to take a thoughtful, data based, yet creative approach to identifying their college prospects.  We start with a thorough self-assessment so that students understand that the goal is to fit college choices to their interests, needs, and abilities, not to do it the other way around.

In light of ever-increasing selectivity to leading colleges, the following thoughts are threaded into our work with students:

  • Students we counsel are reminded constantly that at the very leading colleges, students being turned down are very often as qualified as those being admitted.  In this climate, admitted students very often have every possible qualification, and then something significant more.  If students honestly don’t think they meet this profile, but wish to apply in any case, they should.  But expectation of a positive outcome should be heavily leavened with detached realism.
  • Therefore any list that has the Ivies or similar schools at the top should be well buttressed in the middle and with “back up” schools.  These are the college options that may be offering merit scholarships for strong students, thus becoming very compelling options.  We work closely with each student to assess those possibilities and maximize them.
  • If a student has a strong junior year in terms of testing, grades, and references, an early decision application makes strategic sense if that student has a defined top choice.  We do not encourage Early Admit for strategic reasons alone.  But statistics show that leading college admit higher percentages of the Early Admit pool than does the regular group. (For example, from a recent New York Times blog, this year at Brown 18.54% were admitted early and 8.07% regular; 18.3% early at Princeton and 5.44% regular, and at Penn 24.85% early and 9.4% regular.)
  • Don’t get too excited about an Ivy League wait list.  While we have worked with students who have been admitted from the wait list, the odds are against it.  Cornell this year wait-listed 3,142; Penn wait-listed 2,800 and Yale 1,000.  Play it out if you wish, but begin to move on in emotional and practical terms.

Sarah C. Reese, Informed Educational Solutions

This entry was posted in Academic Consultant, Applications, Best Fit School, College, College Admission Statistics, College Admissions, College Applications, Early Action, Early Decision, Educational Consultant, Educational Counselor, Educational Solutions, High School Grades, Informed Educational Solutions, Ivy League, Optimized Educational Placement, parenting, Sarah C. Reese, School Options, school success, Self-Assessment, social fit, specialized interests, State of College Admission, Timing the Application, Uncategorized, Waitlist and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Creating College Lists and Navigating Admission Decisions

  1. Pingback: More Details on “Shwarzman Scholars” at Tsinghua University | Informed Educational Solutions

  2. Pingback: Looking to Streamline and Organize the College Application Process? – Basic overview of the IESolutions Student Portal | Informed Educational Solutions

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s